Sixteen Myths About Population
By William N. Ryerson
President, Population Media Center
(Originally published by Carrying Capacity Network)
Many
of the policies and spending priorities aimed at curbing population
growth have been based on a combination of inadequate data, wishful
thinking and faulty logic. To resolve some of the misconceptions
about population issues, there is a need for expanded scientific
research using experimental designs to gather conclusive evidence
about the relative effects of various approaches to curbing population
growth.
If population growth is one of the world's most serious problems,
you wouldn't know it from the relatively small investment of
money and strategic thinking provided by the nations of the world.
Altogether, the developed nations of the world contribute less
than a billion dollars a year toward family planning assistance
in developing countries. This is less than four days' budget
of the U.S. Department of Agriculture. It is less than half
the cost of one stealth bomber. If we really want to accelerate
the solution to the population problem, we will need to invest
collectively far more now. For there is little doubt that a population
doubling from 5.5 billion to 11 billion will have far greater
impact than the doubling we have just experienced in the last
40 years.
Many population myths are based on unverifiable or imaginary
relationships. Often, however, beliefs about population are based
on interesting and plausible-sounding correlations (yet unproven)
that may provide hints of possible relationships.
Someone once said, "Hell is truth, seen too late."
Many policy makers and funders have been reluctant to recognize
overwhelming evidence that some of their pet beliefs are countered
by impressive evidence.
The predominant myths about population include:
- Misconceptions about the nature of the problem
- The belief that population growth poses no threat
- The belief we cannot do anything about population growth;
and
- Beliefs about simple approaches that are mistakenly believed
to hold promise of a quick fix to the population problem
In the list above, the fourth area (interventions intended
to solve the population problem) is the most important for those
concerned with population policies. How should the world spend
its limited resources in order to most rapidly bring about diminution
of population growth and ultimate stabilization of numbers? While
there are important and widely held myths even among population
professionals, there is also good news that is not widely known.
There are interventions that have been shown to rapidly bring
about reductions in desired family size and actual fertility.
Some of these interventions are described at the end of this
paper.
Contents:
- Misconceptions About the Nature of the Proplem
- The Belief That Population Growth Poses No Threat
- The Belief We Cannot Do Anything About Population Growth
- Beliefs About Simple Approaches That Are Mistakenly Believed to Hold Promise of a Quick Fix to the Population Problem
- The Centrality of Motivation
- Solutions to the Population Problem
- References
[ Next ]
|